Governments Harmed Children With Wrong Covid Practice

– March 21, 2022

One of the awful ironies of the pandemic lockdowns is that the people least at risk from Covid were among those whom the lockdowns hurt the most. We refer, of course, to the restrictions placed on children. Parks, zoos, and swimming pools were shut down. Little League seasons were cancelled. In many states schools went remote for over a year. The evidence shows that these disruptions have had a substantial impact on children’s learning, their expected lifetime incomes, their life expectancies, and their mental health. The kids are not alright.

Last December, Karyn Lewis and Megan Kuhfeld, two researchers at NWEA, a research organization, reported that student achievement at the start of the current school year was lower than for a typical year. There was a 3–7 percentage point decline in reading and a 9–11 percentage point decline in mathematics. That same month, education researchers Dan Goldhaber of the University of Washington, Thomas J. Kane of Harvard, and Andrew McEachin of NWEA plugged the Lewis/Kuhfeld data into a model to estimate how much those declines in learning would cause their lifetime income to decline. Their answer: $43,800. This number was broadly consistent with a separate study by McKinsey & Company that found an average lifetime earnings loss of between $49,000–$61,000 per student. Aggregated across all US K-12 students, these studies show more than $2 trillion in lost lifetime earnings for our youngest generation.

A recent report released by the World Bank paints a more dire picture. In that report, it estimates that the school closures could cause a loss of between 0.3 and 1.1 years of schooling, adjusted for quality. In its most pessimistic scenario, the World Bank estimates that worldwide cumulative losses could total between $16 and $20 trillion in present value terms.

A National Bureau of Economic Research study released in November 2021 analysed recent test score data across 12 states in comparison to previous years and found passing rates declined by 14.2 percentage points on average in mathematics and 6.3 percentage points in English Language Arts. The authors found that much of the decline was due to the closing down of schools.

Historical evidence suggests that these learning losses are likely to be permanent. A 2019 article published in the Journal of Labor Economics analysed the effect of teacher strikes in Argentina on students’ long-term outcomes in that country. The authors found that experiencing the average number of days of strikes during primary school reduced labor earnings of males and females by 3.2 percent and 1.9 percent, respectively.

In another study, researchers from the IZA Institute of Labor Economics analysed long-term outcomes from one of the most extreme examples of learning disruptions – war. In that study, the authors compared Austrians and Germans who were 10 years old during World War II with their counterparts in neutral countries such as Switzerland and Sweden. The authors found that earning losses persisted into the 1980s. They estimated the earning losses to be about 0.8 percent of GDP.

Once these earning losses take hold, they lead to lower life expectancies. This connection was highlighted most prominently in a paper published in the Journal of the American Medical Association that analysed data on school shutdowns early in the pandemic. The authors found that missed instruction in the United States could be associated with an estimated 13.8 million years of life lost.

What makes these outcomes even more tragic is that they were experienced by children who, as was known early on, never had a significant risk of dying from COVID-19. As of the first week of March 2022, out of the nearly 950,000 Covid-19 deaths, only 865 were children under the age of 18. That amounts to about 433 children annually. This is comparable to a bad flu season in the US. For example, the CDC estimates that the actual number of flu deaths for children in the 2017-18 flu season was about 600.

Moreover, the school closings and lockdowns have led to a noticeable loss in children’s mental health. This was apparent early in the pandemic. In a CDC report released in November 2020, researchers reported that the proportion of mental health-related visits from April to October 2020 for children aged 5-11 and 12-17 years had increased by approximately 24 percent and 31 percent, respectively in comparison to 2019 data. In a follow-up CDC report, researchers found that emergency department visits due to suspected suicide attempts were 51 percent higher among girls aged 12-17 years during early 2021 in comparison to the same period in 2019; among boys aged 12-17 years, suspected suicide attempt emergency department visits increased 4 percent.

In 2021, FAIR Health released a report that analysed data from over 32 billion private health care claim records tracking data from 2019 and 2020. Claims for intentional self-harm as a percentage of all medical claims in the 13-18 age group were 90.7 percent higher early in the pandemic in 2020 than in the same time period in 2019. Furthermore, the authors noted, claims for generalized anxiety disorder increased by 93.6 percent over that same time.

Not much can be done about this now, other than to end the remaining restrictions on children. But there is a lesson for future pandemics: follow the science. If the data say that young people are at very low risk, then treat them as if they are at very low risk. Maybe we’re all in this together, as the propaganda goes, but we are not equally in this together. Treating children the way government officials did was morally wrong.

David R. Henderson

David R. Henderson

David R. Henderson is a Senior Fellow with the American Institute for Economic Research.

He is also a research fellow with the Hoover Institution at Stanford University and emeritus professor of economics with the Naval Postgraduate School, is editor of The Concise Encyclopedia of Economics.

David was previously the senior economist for health policy with President Reagan’s Council of Economic Advisers.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Other recent posts

Going Into a Grand Solar Minimum so Cold Weather Ahead

Going Into a Grand Solar Minimum so Cold Weather Ahead

ELECTROVERSE DOCUMENTING EARTHCHANGES DURING THE NEXT GRAND SOLAR MINIMUM FRESH SNOWFALL HITS NORTHWESTERN PEAKS; COLD RECORDS FALL IN MONTANA AND ALBERTA; FROSTS HIT THE AUSSIE TROPICS; MICHAEL MANN: TOOL OF THE ESTABLISHMENT; + THREE BIG SUNSPOTS JUNE 19, 2024 CAP...

read more
Take Your mRNA shot & Become a Transhuman

Take Your mRNA shot & Become a Transhuman

Karen Kingston: Pfizer Charged with Conspiracy, mRNA Shots Have Transhuman Purpose By Geopolitics & EmpireJune 18, 2024 TwitterTelegramLinkedIn SHARE Karen Kingston discusses a new lawsuit charging Pfizer with conspiracy to commit fraud and unconscionable acts...

read more
Muslims Been Raping Other Women From 7th Century

Muslims Been Raping Other Women From 7th Century

Jihadists Brutalize Non-Muslim Women, Feminists in West Remain Silent by Uzay Bulut June 19, 2024 Today, June 19, the United Nations will observe the annual International Day for the Elimination of Sexual Violence in Conflict. Yet, it took the UN five months to...

read more
We Face a Transhumanist World, Only God’s World is Safe

We Face a Transhumanist World, Only God’s World is Safe

NER: This is a complex subject and I'm quite sure the majority will not be able to grasp it. Yuval Noah Harari has explained it several times, from the technocratic perspective. There’s no doubt that his apparently outlandish ideas, of the redundancy of the billions...

read more
Freedom Under Attack & Only We the People Can Save It

Freedom Under Attack & Only We the People Can Save It

Fight Them Until Hell Freezes Over And then Fight Them on the Ice JUSTUS R. HOPE JUN 16, 2024 RFK Jr. said this about the fight to preserve our Bill of Rights and Constitution while speaking at the Nixon Library. Our Founding Fathers knew that our God-given rights are...

read more
Communist Pope Thankfully Still Against Abortion

Communist Pope Thankfully Still Against Abortion

Pope Attended First G7 Meeting – Are AI Systems Sentient Beings? Posted Jun 17, 2024 By Martin Armstrong This week marked the first time in history that a Catholic pope attended a G7 summit. Italy’s Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, host of the summit, first announced...

read more
Globalist Attack on Your Food Supply, RESIST Them

Globalist Attack on Your Food Supply, RESIST Them

Crisis Update - Dutch Farmers Need Us: If They Fall, We're Next The Hague is infiltrated; shadowy networks drive 'nitrogen' farago NOV 12, 2022 As supply chains fail, the EU is forcing the Netherlands to give up its self-sufficiency. Europe’s agricultural miracle, run...

read more
Climate Scam an Obvious Fraud But Check Movie

Climate Scam an Obvious Fraud But Check Movie

Producer of Climate: The Movie Tom Nelson: Climate Scare Will Crumble Sooner Than You Expect “There's not going to be a big revelation where people say we were wrong completely and sorry about that. They're just going to stop talking about it.” HANNES SARV JUN 07,...

read more