Pre-Covid Scam Was Ongoing Man-Made-Warming Scam

The Red Queen Would Be Proud of the Impossibly Inconsistent Climate Disaster Claims

H. Sterling Burnett
Posted: Jul 20, 2021 12:01 AM
 The Red Queen Would Be Proud of the Impossibly Inconsistent Climate Disaster Claims

Climate alarmists have a problem presenting a consistent narrative on the dangers supposed human-caused climate change poses.

Instead, they follow Lewis Carroll’s irrepressible and violent Red Queen down the climate change rabbit hole, as when in response to Alice’s statement that “one can’t believe impossible things,” she proudly proclaimed, “I daresay you haven’t had much practice. When I was younger, I always did it for half an hour a day. Why, sometimes I’ve believed as many as six impossible things before breakfast.”

Replace the word “impossible” with “contradictory” and you’ll get my point. Over the past two decades, the mainstream media have regularly reported claims that human-caused climate change will bring on both the disappearance of snow and increased snowfall. In 2013, for example, The Daily Telegraph ran an article titled “Children Just Aren’t Going to Know What Snow Is.” In 2014, The New York Times ran an article titled “The End of Snow?” Each story claimed human-caused climate change would result in snow becoming a rare and possibly unheard-of event in the near future in places where snow has historically been common.

More recently, however, as we have documented at our Climate Realism website, climate scientists and their allies in the mainstream media have changed their story to explain multiple instances of record-setting cold and snowfall over the past decade. In the words of a Science Daily article, “Major north-eastern U.S. snowstorms expected to continue with climate change.”

Climate change may contribute to making snowfall more common or less common, but it can’t do both. Importantly, hard data support neither the claim that climate change is causing a dearth of snow nor the claim it is causing extreme snowfall. Media hype to the contrary, there has been no significant trend in snowfall over the recent period of modest warming.

Moving on to other inglorious instances of oft-asserted contradictory climate change claims, in recent years the mainstream media have alternately claimed climate change will cause the water levels of the Great Lakes to rise and fall. Clearly, no contradiction there.

That’s not all. As duly reported by the unthinking media, experts have claimed climate change on and around the Great Lakes will cause both dangerously higher wind speeds and equally disruptive lower wind speeds.

Looking abroad, climate alarmists promote mutually exclusive disaster scenarios in India as being driven by climate change. Heartland Institute President James Taylor recently called out the media’s inconsistent statements about monsoon rains in South Asia. Taylor noted India Today recently claimed new research shows global warming will cause stronger Indian and South Asian monsoons and rainfall, which will wreak climate havoc in future decades. But in 2020, the Hindustan Times reported that peer reviewed research demonstrated global warming will weaken monsoons and reduce monsoon rainfall, with disastrous effects.

In response to the contradictory claims, Taylor asked a fair question: “So, which is it? Does global warming strengthen monsoons and cause more rainfall, which we are told is bad? Or does global warming weaken monsoons and cause less rainfall, which we are told is bad?” Of course, another peer reviewed study found climate change has had almost no impact on monsoons.

“Curiouser and curiouser,” as Alice of Wonderland fame exclaimed.

As award-winning meteorologist Anthony Watts pointed out recently, above or below-average snowfall, monsoon rains, or rising or falling Great Lake levels or wind speeds may be indications of climate change, but only if a single, consistent direction of change is sustained over decades. If, instead, these patterns shift back and forth annually or every few years, that’s just normal weather.

Alarmists have to pick a unified narrative of disaster scenarios and stick with it. If data disprove the narrative, they must admit the theory of catastrophic human-caused global warming is wrong. As Watts said, “You can’t have it both ways.”

I’m weary of progressives desperately clinging to the theory of catastrophic climate change in the face of confounding data and contradictory predictions. I’m tired of their gross public displays of cognitive dissonance, twisting any unexpected weather event into further proof of climate change even when it is inconsistent with previous types of weather events they said climate change should cause or is causing.

Please, environmental socialists, move on to the next hobgoblin you will try to terrify the public with in your continuing effort to expand the government’s, and by extension your own, power over peoples’ lives. I’m ready for a new mythical dragon to slay.

H. Sterling Burnett, Ph.D.(hburnett@heartland.orgis a senior fellow at The Heartland Institute, a nonpartisan, non-profit research centre headquartered in Arlington Heights, Illinois.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Other recent posts

Central Bank Digital Currency, Your Blue Pill To Oblivion

Central Bank Digital Currency, Your Blue Pill To Oblivion

Cashless Society Talk Goes Mainstream in a Hurry and Should Be Trusted Like the NSA We’re on the brink of a dramatic change where we’re about to — and I’ll say this boldly — we’re about to abandon the traditional system of money, and accounting, and introduce a new...

read more
US Hegemon Still Flexing Its Failing Muscles, To No Avail

US Hegemon Still Flexing Its Failing Muscles, To No Avail

A Plan for Global Tyranny By Llewellyn H. Rockwell, Jr. November 28, 2022 In the past few decades, a slogan that threatens to destroy the world has become popular. This is the “rules-based international order.” According to this idea, all nations are supposed to...

read more
US Hegemon Wants Russia Weakened Then China Destroyed

US Hegemon Wants Russia Weakened Then China Destroyed

It Was Never About Ukraine BY TYLER DURDEN SATURDAY, NOV 26, 2022 Authored by Ted Snider via Anti-War.com, In his March 21 press briefing, State Department spokesman Ned Price told the gathered reporters that “President Zelenskyy has also made it very clear that he is...

read more
Vaxxing The World To Oblivion, The Globalist Plan

Vaxxing The World To Oblivion, The Globalist Plan

World Shadow Government Has Built a Global Vaccine Regime That Has Infiltrated Governments and Public Health Institutions BY RHODA WILSON ON NOVEMBER 27, 2022 The same organisations that have an interest in vaccinations today also had a lot of influence in laying the...

read more
Government Is Your Enemy & Enslavement Your Future

Government Is Your Enemy & Enslavement Your Future

The Purposeful Drive Toward Economic Feudalism Is Our Future By Gary D. Barnett November 26, 2022 “Any society that entails the strengthening of the state apparatus by giving it unchecked control over the economy, and re-unites the polity and the economy, is an...

read more
US Hegemon Thrashing Wildly In Its Death Throes

US Hegemon Thrashing Wildly In Its Death Throes

The 'War of Terror' May Be About to Hit Europe By Pepe Escobar Press TV November 26, 2022 Never underestimate a wounded and decaying Empire collapsing in real time. Imperial functionaries, even in a “diplomatic” capacity, continue to brazenly declare that their...

read more
Clear Evidence Vaxxed Can Shed Graphene To Unvaxxed

Clear Evidence Vaxxed Can Shed Graphene To Unvaxxed

Confidential Pfizer Documents & New Study confirm COVID ‘Vaccine Shedding’ has been occurring with shocking & dangerous consequences BY THE EXPOSÉ ON NOVEMBER 26, 2022 A study conducted by scientists at the University of Colorado confirms the vast majority of...

read more