The Commons & Why Socialism is a Failed System

ECONOMYCOMMENTARY

No Private Property Almost Killed Off the Pilgrims

 width=

No individual pilgrim owned crops they grew, so no one had an incentive to work harder to produce extra to sell to others. Since even slackers got food from the communal supply, they had no incentive to work hard. Many didn’t. (Photo: Painting by J.L.M. Ferris via Getty Images)

Happy Thanksgiving!

But beware the “tragedy of the commons.” It almost killed off the pilgrims.

Now, via Washington, D.C., it’s probably coming for us.

Tragedy of the commons is a concept from an essay by ecologist Garrett Hardin. He wrote how cattle ranchers sharing a common parcel of land soon destroy that land. That’s because each rancher has an incentive to put cattle on the common. Soon, the extra animals eat all the grass. Shared grazing space is destroyed because no rancher has an incentive to conserve.

If the ranchers put up a few fences and divide the land, each rancher has an incentive to limit grazing. That saves the grass and the cattle.

Sharing things and “public” property sound nice, but only private ownership reliably inspires people to conserve and protect.

No one washes a rental car.

I bring this up now because the Democrats’ new multitrillion-dollar spending bills are all about expanding the commons: more free highways, free health care, free day care, free money for parents, housing subsidies, tax credits for electric vehicles, etc.

All these handouts discourage responsibility by making it easier to take from the “commons.”

Save for retirement? Why? The government will cover it. Save up for college? Why? Government will give you grants and loans and then forgive those loans.

I bring this up now because this same sort of thinking nearly killed the pilgrims.

When they came to America, the pilgrims decided to share everything. The governor of Plymouth Colony, William Bradford, wrote that the pilgrims thought “taking away of property and (making it communal) … would make them happy and flourishing.”

Food and supplies were distributed based on need. Pilgrims would not selfishly produce food for themselves.

In other words, they, like Sen. Bernie Sanders and many American young people today, fell in love with the idea of socialism.

The result was ugly. When the first harvest came, there wasn’t nearly enough food. Many pilgrims died that winter. If the Wampanoag American Indians hadn’t helped them, all might have starved.

It was the tragedy of the commons. No individual pilgrim owned crops they grew, so no one had an incentive to work harder to produce extra to sell to others. Since even slackers got food from the communal supply, they had no incentive to work hard.

Many didn’t.

Strong men thought it was an “injustice” that they “had no more in division of victuals and clothes than he that was weak and not able to do a quarter the other could.” Women had to cook and clean for other women’s husbands, and they “deemed it a kind of slavery.”

The shared farming, Bradford concluded, “was found to breed much confusion and discontent and retard much employment that would have been to their benefit.”

When the Pilgrims ran out of food, they “began to think how they might raise as much corn as they could, and obtain a better crop … that they might not still thus languish in misery.”

Their solution was private property. They split up the collective farm and gave every family a plot of land.

That was a big success. “It made all hands very industrious, so as much more corn was planted than otherwise would have been,” wrote Bradford. “The women now went willingly into the field, and took their little ones with them to set corn.” Before, they “would allege weakness and inability.”

Thanks to individual plots of land, food shortages turned into a surplus that became the feast we now call Thanksgiving.

“All men have this corruption,” Bradford observed. In a common, everyone wants to take as much as they can.

Private property created prosperity.

This Thanksgiving, I’m thankful for private property.

It’s why I can eat turkey.

COPYRIGHT 2021 BY JFS PRODUCTIONS INC.

Have an opinion about this article? To sound off, please email letters@DailySignal.com and we’ll consider publishing your edited remarks in our regular “We Hear You” feature. Remember to include the URL or headline of the article plus your name and town and/or state.

3 Comments

  1. willowy

    Τhanks , I hаve recently been looking for іnformation ɑpproximately this subјect for a while and
    yours is the greatest I have came upon till now.
    Ꮋⲟwever, what in regards to the bottom line? Are
    you positive in regards to the source?

    Reply
    • Neville

      Thanks Willowy.I started this blog in May 2020 when I first saw through the Covid scam. My sole purpose was to warn people, as I knew the vax would be a kill/disabling device as part of the WEF/Great Reset depopulation agenda. Because the truth is so difficult to find I have spent 10 hours/day 7 days per week seeking it.Because of the necessity to research, I come across other things which are either of particular interest or of importance. Hence I blog on Ukraine because I know the truth, & none of it is in the MSM. Also I have known about the AGW scam for two decades & its important that you know about that. The Commons article is from a reliable source & the logic of his argument is in accordance with what I believe to be true.

      Reply
  2. topmost

    Link exchange is nothing еlse but it is simply placing the other persօn’s blog link on your
    page at approprіate place and othеr person will ɑlso do same in favor of you.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Other recent posts

Freedom Under Attack & Only We the People Can Save It

Freedom Under Attack & Only We the People Can Save It

Fight Them Until Hell Freezes Over And then Fight Them on the Ice JUSTUS R. HOPE JUN 16, 2024 RFK Jr. said this about the fight to preserve our Bill of Rights and Constitution while speaking at the Nixon Library. Our Founding Fathers knew that our God-given rights are...

read more
Communist Pope Thankfully Still Against Abortion

Communist Pope Thankfully Still Against Abortion

Pope Attended First G7 Meeting – Are AI Systems Sentient Beings? Posted Jun 17, 2024 By Martin Armstrong This week marked the first time in history that a Catholic pope attended a G7 summit. Italy’s Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, host of the summit, first announced...

read more
Globalist Attack on Your Food Supply, RESIST Them

Globalist Attack on Your Food Supply, RESIST Them

Crisis Update - Dutch Farmers Need Us: If They Fall, We're Next The Hague is infiltrated; shadowy networks drive 'nitrogen' farago NOV 12, 2022 As supply chains fail, the EU is forcing the Netherlands to give up its self-sufficiency. Europe’s agricultural miracle, run...

read more
Climate Scam an Obvious Fraud But Check Movie

Climate Scam an Obvious Fraud But Check Movie

Producer of Climate: The Movie Tom Nelson: Climate Scare Will Crumble Sooner Than You Expect “There's not going to be a big revelation where people say we were wrong completely and sorry about that. They're just going to stop talking about it.” HANNES SARV JUN 07,...

read more
Putin Also Guilty of Joining Vax Depopulation Agenda

Putin Also Guilty of Joining Vax Depopulation Agenda

Covid Russia: It’s not the government that’s saving Russians, it is the people saving themselves BY RHODA WILSON ON JUNE 8, 2024 Many have claimed that Russia has fared better than most large countries during the covid era and the subsequent vaccine era.  After...

read more
Julianne Smith Replacing Nuland, Both Satanic Warmongers

Julianne Smith Replacing Nuland, Both Satanic Warmongers

NER: If you listen to this 5 minute video you will hear a constant stream of lies from the mouth of Julianne Smith. Russia did absolutely nothing in 2014. It was Victoria Nuland with the CIA who instituted the Maidan uprising to overthrow the duly elected President....

read more
Americas Wealth Destroying Military Industrial Complex

Americas Wealth Destroying Military Industrial Complex

The Military-Industrial Complex Is Killing Us All Freeing Ourselves from the Monster Destroying Our Planet and Our Futures By Theresa (Isa) Arriola and David Vine TomDispatch.com June 5, 2024 We need to talk about what bombs do in war. Bombs shred flesh. Bombs shatter...

read more
Jeffrey Sachs Exposing Deep State & Nuclear Threats

Jeffrey Sachs Exposing Deep State & Nuclear Threats

NER: This is an incredibly insightful talk from Jeffrey Sachs, a must watch. He's one of the most brilliant & experienced commentators around. Jeffrey Sachs with probably the smartest and most accurate assessment of the Ukraine war, and American foreign policy...

read more